Established in New York 1972
Best exemplifying what a Legacy representative should be; primarily a football award (but included basketball or lacrosse some years)
1972 Myron Bell
1973 Roy Messinger
1974 Tommy Spatafora
1975 Chris Duffy
Eddie Mangiarotti
1976 Mike Langford
1977 Joe Sweeney
1978 Jack Barr
Established in New York 1972
Best exemplifying what a Legacy representative should be; primarily a football award (but included basketball or lacrosse some years)
1972 Myron Bell
1973 Roy Messinger
1974 Tommy Spatafora
1975 Chris Duffy
Eddie Mangiarotti
1976 Mike Langford
1977 Joe Sweeney
1978 Jack Barry
1979 Troy Quackenbush
1980 Wally Cohen
1981 Kevin Clifford
1982 Ricky Deming
1983 John Flath
1984 J.J. Miller
1985 Brad Bolton
1986 Mario Ambrosio
1987 Chris Caldwell
Nick Caldwell
1988 J.R. Billingsley
Leroy Jackson
1989 Josh Greer
1990 Andy Neufeld
1991 David Zickafoose
1992 Jason Watts
1993 Marcus Mickens
1994 Zack Daughtry
1995 Kevin Jackson
1996 Christian Sanders
1997 Nick Tenekedes
1998 Matt Ford
1999 Scott Ramey
2000 Will Harrison
2001 Dan Payne
2002 Ray Brown
2003 Joey Furjanic
Lee Sloan
2004 Jeremy Francis
2005 Justin Brownell
Cody Mey
Established in New York 1976
Based on athletic ability and gentlemanly ways; primarily a baseball award (but included softball or lacrosse or basketball or soccer or football)
1976 Chris Duffy
1977 Chris Eckert
1978 Terri Fry
1979 Pat LaCore
1980 Alan Banyacski
1981 Jeff Wolf
1982 Robert Bliss
1983 John McKay
1984 E.J. Ro
Established in New York 1976
Based on athletic ability and gentlemanly ways; primarily a baseball award (but included softball or lacrosse or basketball or soccer or football)
1976 Chris Duffy
1977 Chris Eckert
1978 Terri Fry
1979 Pat LaCore
1980 Alan Banyacski
1981 Jeff Wolf
1982 Robert Bliss
1983 John McKay
1984 E.J. Rossow
1985 Brian Hendrix
1986 Jason Alford
1987 Chris Stokes
1988 Chris Tulip
MIke Rugienius
1989 Brian McMahon
Aaron Church
1990 Andy Sarasty
1991 Ryan Alkire
1992 John Salas
1993 Richie Schneck
1994 Ryan Rinaldi
1995 John Hernandez
1996 Richie DiTore
1997 Rich Kline
1998 Brian Wallace
1999 Mary Kate O'Rourke
2000 Tyrone Foster
2001 Katie Christie
2002 Nik Holmes
2003 Vernon Foster
2004 Mattea Codrey
2005 Ryan Gillard
Established in Florida 1982
Awarded to the individual that portrays the characteristics of both a good player and person: talent, sportsmanship, leadership, and hustle; primarily a basketball award (but included lacrosse and track & field/cross-country)
1982 Hayward Beasley
1983 Phil Florence
1984 Garth Bolton
1985 Danny Rubin
1986
Established in Florida 1982
Awarded to the individual that portrays the characteristics of both a good player and person: talent, sportsmanship, leadership, and hustle; primarily a basketball award (but included lacrosse and track & field/cross-country)
1982 Hayward Beasley
1983 Phil Florence
1984 Garth Bolton
1985 Danny Rubin
1986 Bryan Hart
1987 Bryan Hart
Pam Lindsey
1988 Mark Bellhorn
Kenny Kroog
1989 Kelly Walters
1990 Brian Buchanan
Bubba Lamb
1990 SPECIAL CAREER WALLER AWARD
Timmy Slavik
1991 Stephanie Noiseux
1992 Carrie McAuliffe
Shydonna Tossie
1993 Seth Fowler
1994 Stacy Kolb
1995 Cary Muehler
1996 Chrissy Wheeler
1997 Kenny Starling
1998 Ryan Roberts
1999 Frank Stratton
2000 Mike Sheets
2001 Kevin Liljenquist
2002 Jimmy Duda
2003 Scott Burns
2004 Joey Rodriguez
2005 Jenny Barringer
Established in Florida 1988
Given to a former player (Alumni) that has gone on to further success -- be it athletic, academic, or giving back to youth athletics or the community in other ways.
1988 Willy Daunic
1989 Darryn Crist
Doug Robbins
1990 Terri Kaleel
Frank Scucci
1991 Harry Waller
1992 Chris Stron
Established in Florida 1988
Given to a former player (Alumni) that has gone on to further success -- be it athletic, academic, or giving back to youth athletics or the community in other ways.
1988 Willy Daunic
1989 Darryn Crist
Doug Robbins
1990 Terri Kaleel
Frank Scucci
1991 Harry Waller
1992 Chris Stronko
1993 Danny Rubin
1994 Barry Coleman
1995 Bob Ottewill
Joe Forte
1996 Jason Crawley
1997 Cary Muehler
1998 Gary Lamberta
1999 Brian Wallace
Phil Weber
2000 Chucky Atkins
2001 Todd Bellhorn
Hutch VanderSchuyt
2002 Matt Reedy
Sammy Siciliano
2003 Frank Driscoll
2004 Reggie Kohn
Mark Bellhorn
2005 Jered Goodwin
Joey Crocco
Established in New York & Florida, 2025
Presented in the honor of the long-time Huntington resident who was an advocate of female athletics, softball hall-of-famer, YMCA program director, and youth sports volunteer.
Awarded to those women who brought notoriety to women's and girl's sports in their respective areas and doing so with class, g
Established in New York & Florida, 2025
Presented in the honor of the long-time Huntington resident who was an advocate of female athletics, softball hall-of-famer, YMCA program director, and youth sports volunteer.
Awarded to those women who brought notoriety to women's and girl's sports in their respective areas and doing so with class, grit, and sportsmanship.
NEW YORK WINNERS
The 1971 Huntington YMCA Mice
FLORIDA WINNERS
Phylllis Baynes
Christy Tibbitts Bryce
Anna Hollis
Pam Lindsey
Debbi Pegel
Terri Fry Staley
Janet Williams